the problem with publicising scientific articles without peer review

-
The COVID-19 pandemic has pushed medical and data scientists into placing their results and their interpretations out into the public as pre-prints; many of which are not reviewed by their peers and may be premature. I find such practice very disturbing because many of these studies have been done hurriedly and are immature. 

As a scientist who has been tapped by technical journals to review articles in food science and rice genetics, and rice grain quality (plus the occasional request from Val to pore over thousands of rice science articles to help him find and summarise impact assessment studies... which I do using natural language processing), I have seen my fair share of papers which shouldn't see the light of day because the authors did not demonstrate that the methodologies they applied or their interpretations of their results are solid.

It's almost like receiving your undergraduate degree or your graduate degree without having your research manuscript, thesis, or dissertation undergo an assessment from experts either through an internal review and public defence in uni (which was what I did to complete my BSc degree in Biology from the University of the Philippines Los Baños) or an external review by a panel of experts from three different institutes (which was what my thesis underwent before I received my PhD degree from the University of Queensland).

Anyway, back to the scientists racing to publish their work on COVID-19... 

I know that many of these medical scientists just want their results out in the open to help people make decisions regarding patient care, flattening the epidemic curve, and kickstarting the global economy so that people don't go hungry. However, without the peer review process, many of the logical gaps these scientists present don't get caught and fixed. This leads to misinformation and/or misinterpretation by policymakers, government officials, and journalists. It has even led to at least one death because a tv viewer mistook an aquarium cleaner for the same medicine being touted as a cure for the disease.

Do I really need to mention the biggest bumbling example who keeps showing up on the telly these days, whose speeches are solid (a testament at how good the writers are) but keep breaking down into illogical pieces upon being picked for information during the Q&A portion? This person is a perfect example of a scientific "cherry-picker", promoting possible therapies forcibly (on-script) then backing off with the line "I am not a medical expert" (off-script). 

But I've digressed (again)...

On social media, I've seen data scientists who love to crunch the COVID-19 numbers, find trends, and present their interpretations to their wider audience as "scientific" blogs; totally eschewing the peer review process. This, I think, is even more disturbing because there is absolutely no filter. For pre-prints, scientists who glean over the articles can point out mistakes and the authors can withdraw their paper or improve it for eventual publication in journals and to inform policy dialogue. But the data scientists probably don't realise that they don't have the essential technical background to create a medically sound story about the epidemic, particularly if they haven't teamed up with epidemiologist/s. It's like being an armchair expert and claiming that your work is solid. The most responsible thing that these data scientists can do is to NOT publicise their work!

Comments

Post a Comment

Thank you for dropping by!

Before moving on, please share your thoughts or comments about the post. :)

Thanks again!

Popular posts from this blog

Skyflakes

-
One of the more famous Philippine exports is Skyflakes , a wheat-based, salty cracker. It is one of my emergency food items: I typically have some stocked at home and in my handbag in case I become hungry (like in traffic jams). When there's no electricity and it's impractical to cook rice (because the leftover would spoil), I'd open a pack of Skyflakes and generously coat each cracker with Cheez Whiz... if I had a bottle of it within reach. Anyway, each time I spent more than two weeks outside the Philippines, I'd be elated to see boxes of Skyflakes inside Asian stores (particularly when in I was Australia and in the USA). Back then, I took it as a sign of homesickness. When I moved to California, I didn't miss Skyflakes because Mommy made sure that there's a steady supply in the house. Skyflakes is embedded in Filipino gastronomy as a snack, a panawid-gutom , that anyone who reacts positively upon seeing Skyflakes outside the Philippines must have spe
Read more

10 things I learned while driving on Marcos Highway to Baguio City

-
I went on a day trip to the City of Pines, which was around a 700-km drive from my house. I drove  going up there and then from the city to Victoria, Tarlac. After that, my dad took over the driving duties. It was day trip with Tita Ising and Tito Sibing with us. Anyway, this trip was my first time to go to Baguio City with me behind the wheel. As everyone who drives up knows, there are three main routes to Baguio from the lowlands: Kennon Road, which ascends from Rosario, La Union. It was out of my options because it's too dangerous to use that road in the rainy season. The second route is via Naguilian Road, which makes my trip a lot longer because the beginning of the ascent is in Bauang, La Union (further north). The last route, and the one I took, was the Marcos Highway, now known as the Aspiras-Palispis Highway. This 47-km road starts from Agoo, La Union and is touted as the safest route among the three.  As I drove up and then down (on the same day; we were in Bagu
Read more

Surat Mangyan

-
Image
In high school, part of the Filipino curriculum was learning about one of the country's ancient native scripts called Baybayin . I learned back then that this script was eventually abandoned because the Spanish, and eventually the Americans, encouraged the use of the Latin script for written communications. But that's in the lowlands; the rules were different up in the mountains. In the lush mountains of Mindoro, groups of indigenous people called Mangyans  live largely in isolation away from the Christianised Filipinos. This isolation has led to the continuous development of the Mangyans' old script, Surat Mangyan . As I walked inside the Ayala Museum , I saw this bamboo tube (I'm not sure if it's an instrument) with Mangyan script written all over it. I suppose that this was equivalent to a book or a song. But I haven't figured out what's written yet, despite the translation guide provided. What I can do, however, is write my name in Ma
Read more